337. Debate(1/2)
"To sum up, the suspect Wang also has a clear motive for the crime and the facts of the crime are affirmed. He requests the judge to give a fair ruling and give justice to the deceased."
"No, I..."
Wang Yi listened to what the judge said and stood up from the seat in anger, but then suppressed the two people next to him.
The judge nodded when he heard the prosecutor's words, then turned to Zhang Wei and asked: "Does the defense lawyer have anything to say?"
When Zhang Wei heard this, he stood up and took out a file bag: "This is the information we obtained this time.
According to what the prosecutor said, it was actually wrong for them to suspect that Wang Yi forged a will and killed the deceased, intending to obtain the property of the deceased."
After hearing this, the prosecutor opposite asked: "Isn't this a problem for a woman who is only 0 years old, but she has left herself a clear will and an unexpected beneficiary?"
According to the forensic anatomy, the deceased did not have any disease that could cause death. What would make a healthy middle-aged man leave a will? We have to doubt it."
Zhang Wei heard the words and said with a smile: "But besides the body, there are other things, such as mental illnesses...
These may allow the deceased to leave a will, confirm after he dies, or make arrangements for himself in the future.”
After hearing this, the prosecutor shook his head: "It is impossible. We have investigated the examinations done by the deceased in the hospital. She has never done this examination.
Even if she had mental illness, she wouldn't have known it herself, let alone making a will for this matter."
Zhang Wei nodded when he heard this, affirming the other party's statement, but changed the subject and said, "It is true. She did not perform corresponding examinations in a regular hospital, but it does not mean that she does not know.
In our daily life, we will notice some mental illnesses.
As an elite woman, the deceased has a lot of pressure in life, so he receives psychological counseling from an exclusive psychologist once a week.
And when she was receiving psychological counseling, she was found to have Alzheimer's disease."
The prosecutor laughed and said, "What? Are you talking about Alzheimer's disease?
I would like to ask if she knew she might have this disease and would not go to a regular hospital for examination.
On the contrary, it is too strange that it leaves a will just a few words from a psychologist, right?”
Zhang Wei heard this and said, "It's really strange, but not strange. As executives of their company, the deceased are one of the highest decision-making levels and must not have any problems, let alone mental illness.
If Mo Company knew that he had this mental illness, he would likely face a series of risks such as firing, so she did not choose to go to the hospital for examination because she was afraid of being discovered.
I just found a doctor privately based on the introduction of my psychologist and determined my condition.
After learning about this disease, there is no complete solution so far, it can only be alleviated and there is no way to cure it.
She realized that she might have a hard life for the rest of her life, and in her opinion, the defendant was her support.
Although my client always said that they were in a supporting relationship, from the perspective of the deceased, this was not the case.
According to my understanding, the deceased is already planning a wedding with my client, so it is more normal for my client to become the beneficiary of the will.
She may be afraid that her condition would worsen before the wedding, so she left this will as a guarantee that her property would be kept in the hands of the person she believed in.
Because she believed that my client would protect her, that's how it was."
Wang Yi, who was sitting next to him, heard this and bit the flesh in his mouth, as if he was thinking about something.
"And I also found a psychologist who specializes in psychological counseling for the deceased. He also made a proof of the facts of this matter.
He did tell the deceased that she was likely to suffer from Alzheimer's disease, which we often call Alzheimer's disease.
The deceased also went to another doctor based on his introduction, but did not leave any files.
Because of the above reasons, the deceased will leave a will."
The prosecutor did not respond when he heard this and did not engage in too much entanglement with Zhang Wei in this regard. He said directly: "Okay, we requested to summon witnesses. He can prove that that night, the deceased and the defendant had a fierce quarrel at the time of the incident.
Instead of, as the defendant said, he had left the community at the time of the incident, the defendant was lying, and the so-called absenteeism proved to be completely fabricated.”
"Agree." The judge nodded when he heard this, and then summoned the witness to court.
"Hello judge, hello everyone, I am Wang Shufeng, who lives in 5806."
A gray-headed but still looking energetic old lady stood in the court and first introduced herself.
"Grandma Wang, I want to ask, you heard the defendant's voice at the time of the incident, right?" The prosecutor looked at Grandma Wang opposite and asked.
Grandma Wang nodded with certainty when she heard this: "Yes, they were quarreling at that time, and they were very fierce. I could hear it in the next house, and I had never quarreled with them before.
Although what was the specific argument? I didn't hear it clearly, I must be the two of them."
Wang Yi heard the other party's words of certainty and shouted excitedly: "Old woman, don't talk nonsense, I'll tell you!
You are false accusation! You are doing perjury! I want to sue you! I sue you!"
The two people next to Wang Yi pressed him down mercilessly.
The judge said with a blank expression: "Sujing, defendant, if you have any extreme behaviors and threaten witnesses, we will let you leave early and will be subject to corresponding criminal punishment."
The old lady looked at the excited Wang Yi and couldn't help but shake her head: "Where did I lie? I can hear it clearly. If you kill someone and pay your life, you can accept it if you owe debts."
"Does the defense lawyer have anything to ask?"
Zhang Wei nodded, turned his head and asked Grandma Wang with a smile: "Grandma, I want to ask, where were you when you heard this sound?"
Grandma Wang heard this and said, "It was midnight at that time, so she must be in the room to go to bed.
At that time, I was lying on the bed and reading a book, and then I heard the voices of the two of them.”
Zhang Wei took out a floor plan and showed it to everyone at the scene: "Okay, let's take a look at the apartment type of the community where the crime occurred. As far as I know, Grandma Wang lives in the B apartment type, right?"
When Grandma Wang heard this, she nodded as expected: "That's right, this apartment is relatively large, 128 square meters, and our family of five must live in a large one."
Zhang Wei took out a pen and drew several circles on the floor plan: "Okay, let's take a look at this floor plan. According to the investigation, two houses on the same floor are of the same type.
According to the floor plan, it can be seen that the two houses are connected together in the living room.
The deceased and the murderer clashed in the living room, while Grandma Wang heard the sound in the bedroom with a wall and a living room.
I would like to ask, at this distance, grandma, is it really possible that you hear this sound?
I don't suspect that you are old and have hearing deterioration, but this distance is indeed a bit too far."
Grandma Wang was a little unhappy when she heard Zhang Wei’s rebuttal: “My ears are very good, there is no problem at all, and they are quarreling too loudly, so I heard it!”
When Zhang Wei heard this, he looked puzzled: "Is this true? But according to the situation on the scene, the glass on the scene was shattered.
The sound of the glass should be quite loud when it breaks. Why didn’t you hear it grandma?”
"It's just that their voices are so loud that I hear it!"
"Is that so? The sound is loud. If a person's voice reaches a certain level, theoretically, the characteristics of his voice are basically impossible to hear.
How did grandma hear from that voice that it must be my client?
As far as I know, grandma and my client are not very familiar with each other!? In such an unfamiliar situation, are you so sure it was his voice? Isn’t there any problem?"
"..." Grandma Wang suddenly felt a little guilty when she heard Zhang Wei's consecutive questions.
Now that I think about it carefully, I can't remember what it was like at that time...
Did you really hear it wrong...
It's hard to say, the sound was not very loud when it came to me...
The prosecutor looked at Grandma Wang who was trapped in self-doubt, and immediately turned to the judge and said, "I suspect that the other party's lawyer is inducing witnesses!"
“The objection is invalid.”
The judge replied when he heard this. According to what Zhang Wei said just now, the old lady's testimony was indeed somewhat doubtful.
Zhang Wei stared at Grandma Wang and said, "Grandma Wang, I want to ask you, you are really sure that the sound you heard that night was my client?"
"I...I'm not sure."
Grandma Wang said weakly when she heard this. She was asked repeatedly several times, but she really couldn't be sure now...
"Okay, thank you." Zhang Wei nodded with a smile when he heard this.
The prosecutor looked at Grandma Wang who was standing in the middle and was somewhat guilty, gritted his teeth and said, "Okay, we ask the next witness to come on stage. He saw the defendant who fled the scene with his own eyes that night."
Although I think I am sure to win, I am still a little unwilling to be overthrown by the other party again and again.
"good."
Zhang Wei smiled slightly when he heard the other party's words. Unfortunately, he had found evidence that he could overturn the testimony of the witnesses not long ago.
A young man stood in the middle with a smile and said, "My name is Xu Jian, 18 years old. That night when I went downstairs to throw the garbage, I saw this person leaving in a hurry."
The prosecutor smiled at the words and said to the teenager: "Are you sure you see the defendant?"
Xu Jian nodded with certainty when he heard this: "That's right, it's just him. Although he didn't see his face, I wouldn't admit it wrong, whether it was his clothes or figure.
Although we are not very familiar with each other, we are also familiar with each other, so I am sure I will not read it wrong.
Could it be that I happened to go back to someone who had a figure similar to him and was wearing the same clothes that night?"
The prosecutor nodded and asked another question: "Okay, I have another question. Did you confirm that you saw the defendant at 10:30 that night?"
Xu Jian nodded with certainty: "Of course, my takeaway arrived that night at about 10 o'clock. After I finished eating the takeaway, I found that the trash can was full.
Then I walked down with the garbage and saw him. It was probably around 10:30, so there was no problem."
"Okay, my question is over." The prosecutor nodded with a smile and said to the judge.
To be continued...