"In other words, there is a difference between the official version and the straight-to-film version of the first verse that Lin Yingxue sang.

"Let's continue listening. Next is the part Fang Xing sings."

He pressed the play button and the two audio clips continued to play.

"The former palace chief was thin

"Taigao Bingbing tears are hard to shed

"After sending off the brocade book, I suddenly looked back

"There's no time left to steal..."

After playing this segment, He Chengyun pressed the pause button again and said:

"The overlap in this section is very high. Unless I have been mixing for many years, I can hardly hear the difference."

Later.

He played the entire song several times, and even played some parts over and over again.

After listening, he opened the audio waveform:

"Okay, next, let's take a look at the waveform."

Melodyne's waveform interface is displayed.

Two audios and two waveforms.

He Chengyun said while comparing: "Actually, it's very clear when you see the waveform diagram.

"The part where Lin Yingxue sings, the two audio waveforms are slightly different.

"In other words, the official version of Lin Yingxue's audio must have been edited, and all the key sounds have been edited, and several key sounds are very accurate.

“Here’s a popular science point of view: sound modification is part of post-production. If we can’t modify sound, then it will be difficult for us as mixers to find jobs.

"This is not to criticize Lin Yingxue, on the contrary, I want to praise Lin Yingxue.

"The audio of the official version and the direct-filmed version are different, which shows that Lin Yingxue must have really sang at the scene.

"Netizens who often watch my videos should know that it is actually very common for actors to lip-sync.

"Actors who are willing to really sing, even if their singing is flawed, are worthy of encouragement."

Identify here.

There are more and more barrages in the live broadcast room:

[We don’t want to see if Lin Yingxue lip-syncs, we want to know if Fang Xing does.]

[Lin Yingxue sang for real, wouldn’t Fang Xing still lip-sync? 】

[It’s hard to say. I just listened to two audios, the official version and the direct-shot version. Fang Xing’s voice overlapped very well. Maybe it was actually a CD played live.]

He Chengyun continued the appraisal and pulled the waveform chart to the part where Fang Xing sang:

"Next is Fang Xing's part, let's look at the waveform diagram first.

“The two waveform images overlap very closely, and there is basically no editing. There are only very subtle differences.

“First of all, let’s do some science. This kind of subtle difference is not necessarily caused by tuning, but may also be caused by poor recording quality.

"After all, the version shot directly by the audience, at first glance, was shot with a mobile phone. It is not a professional recording equipment. It is normal for the recording effect to be poor.

"Comparing the waveforms of the two versions, it can be said that they are basically the same, so just look at the official version.

“The waveform of the official version of Fang Xing’s singing part has a lot of details, and the ups and downs of the waveform are very obvious.

"Based on my experience, I can confirm that the part that Fang Xing sang had a very low degree of later-stage editing, basically no repairs at all.

"So, I personally prefer that he really sang live, and he sang really well.

"Of course, some netizens will definitely ask whether it is possible to record the audio in advance and then play the audio live.

"This possibility exists, but judging from the video we have so far, there is no sign to prove it.

"Furthermore, I have reviewed many of Fang Xing's live broadcast videos, and with his singing skills, he can indeed sing at this level.

"So, my personal conclusion is that Fang Xing really sang at the scene.

"Fang Xing's vocals are also very accurate. Occasionally there are slight deviations in individual vocals, but they are all within the normal range.

“Let’s get some science here. Even if you are a top-level singer, if you sing the same song twice, it will not be exactly the same. It is normal for slight changes in pitch.

"When a singer sings, each emotional expression is different, and the waveform of the voice will naturally change slightly.

"In fact, art is reflected in these subtle changes. If a singer always sings exactly the same, what is the difference between him and a robot?

"The same goes for Shen Jianjia in the back. She has a good background in majors and she really sings on stage.

"Wang Kai also sang for real, but there were some inaccuracies in the direct-to-video video, and the official version has been corrected.

"Finally, let me conclude.

"The song "Know or Not" on "Happy Weekend" was sung by the four people at the scene.

"However, in the official video that TV viewers saw, the parts of Lin Yingxue and Wang Kai were edited, while the parts of Fang Xing and Shen Jianjia were not edited at all.

"This is the conclusion. This is my personal appraisal result and does not represent the facts.

"If fans and netizens have more evidence, they can provide it to me. If it proves that my conclusion is wrong, I will actively correct it.

"That's it for today's live broadcast. Tomorrow, I will intercept this video of the appraisal and send it to my appraisal topic."

【Serious! I believe it.】

[From the perspective of the audience, Lin Yingxue and Wang Kai have actually practiced their pronunciation. Can they be said to be lip-synching?]

[This cannot be said to be lip-synching. It is normal for the post-production of recording and broadcasting programs to be modified. 】

[If the audio editing of the recording and broadcasting program is considered to be lip-syncing, then if Xiangguo Channel uses such a large filter, can it be said that the celebrities have fake faces?]

[Holy shit! This angle is tricky, but it makes sense somehow. 】

[Yes, the recorded and broadcast programs are all lip-syncing. Even if the singing is flawed, it is still worthy of encouragement. Lin Yingxue and Wang Kai are both very good.]

[It’s boring, Fang Xing didn’t even lip-sync, which made me happy for nothing.]

[I clicked in when I saw the title of Fang Xing’s lip-synching, but I’ve already laid out all the melon seeds. Can you show me this?]

【Just be your own people.】

[Fang Xing is truly lucky to have a group of fun fans like you.]
Chapter completed!