Why did Emperor Wen of the Han Dynasty use Huang Lao and the world was stable? Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty used Confucianism and wasted the country?

Without Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, there might have been Emperor Huizong of the Han Dynasty.

Do the Xiongnu in the Han Dynasty, Xixia in the Song Dynasty and the Liao Kingdom mean the same thing?

The Han Dynasty did not need so many soldiers and horses to defend the Xiongnu, and the peace was maintained here. If the Song Dynasty were to defend Xixia, the Liao Kingdom would be destroyed if the heavy troops on the border were withdrawn and the annual tribute was stopped.

So why didn’t the Song Dynasty learn from Emperor Wen of Han?

It is because the governance of the world is different, so the governance is different.

Zhang Yue wrote that Emperor Wen of the Han Dynasty used Huang Lao to govern the country with generosity, so that the people's strength could be cultivated and the treasury could be enriched. Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty did not use Confucianism purely, but adopted the way of kings and hegemons and governed the country strictly. Although the country was wasted at home, it controlled the country.

The success of the Xiongnu's victory over South Vietnam also lies in Emperor Wen's lenient policy of resting the people.

The Song Dynasty had the defeat of Gaolianghe, and the Han Dynasty also had the siege of Baideng, but why did one become stronger and the other decline?

Could the Song Dynasty learn from the Han Dynasty, first be lenient and rest with the people, and then use strict methods to violently invade the country, and finally defeat the Western Xia and Liao Kingdoms?

no.

Zhang Yue's idea of ​​​​this policy is still based on "strengthening the village".

Just like playing stocks, the banker only does two things, attracting funds and raising the stock price.

Acquire funds, increase the chips in hand, and become a strong banker, only then can the stock price rise.

I won’t say whether this conclusion is correct or not.
Chapter completed!